March 28, 2014

The Solution to Crimea Lies Through Finland


The Solution to Crimea Lies Through Finland

You have to hand it to History. She has a very well developed sense of irony.* Exactly 160 years ago today the Crimean War began.

Yes, yes, the war began between Russia and the Ottoman Empire several months earlier, in October 1853. But it was on March 27 and 28, 1854, that France and Britain declared war on Russia, turning a war between neighbors into a global conflagration. (It ought to be called a World War, since fighting was far from limited to Crimea, extending to the Baltic, Caucasus, Pacific, and even the White Sea, where the British bombarded Solovki.)

The Crimean conflict was a very complicated war. Ostensibly it was about settling the borders between the Russian and Ottoman empires, but it was also about control over the holy sites in Jerusalem, about coming to grips with the “sick man” of Europe (the declining Ottoman Empire), about “checking Russian expansion,” and about control of the Black Sea. Read the short or the long version and you will quickly learn how critical a turning point the Crimean War was in world history (leading to important military and medical advances, the end of serfdom in Russia, the Russian sale of Alaska to the US, the fall of a few governments, etc.). And you will also see some startling parallels to the present day, plus how the outlines of the current crisis have their roots in 1854.

But I digress.

While it is useful for the current crisis over Crimea and Ukraine to understand history, solving the crisis is more likely through analogy. But first we must understand the motivations of the actors involved.

There has been no shortage of ink spilled to explain Kremlin motivations and actions in Ukraine, but to my mind just one passes the Occam’s Razor test. It was succinctly expressed by Michael Totten (who gets extra points for citing George Kennan):

“What [Putin] most fears is that Ukraine might join NATO, removing yet another buffer state between himself and the West and kiboshing his plans for the Eurasian Union.... The Crimean referendum—whether it was free and fair or rigged is no matter—creates a disputed territory conflict that will never be resolved in Ukraine’s favor. It will freeze and fester indefinitely. There isn’t a chance that NATO would accept a member that has a disputed territory conflict with Russia. No chance at all. Ukraine is as isolated as it could possibly be from the West without getting re-absorbed into Russia entirely.

 

“Putin did the same thing to Georgia in 2008 when he lopped off the regions of South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and he did it for the same reason.

 

“A similar dynamic fell into his lap in Moldova, the poor and battered country east of Romania. The far eastern Slavic region of (Latin) Moldova declared independence after the Soviet period and calls itself Transnistria....

 

“That’s not one, not two, but three times Russia has pulled this stunt since the end of the Cold War. Putin is doing it to Ukraine because it worked in Moldova and Georgia.”

As to the Endgame, Totten is equally direct: “There is no exit plan. Russia is not going to pull out of these countries, nor will anyone force Russia out. It’s not worth a world war—not even close.”

Ok, so if we assume that summarizes Putin’s actions and motivations, what about the West? Well, while some (say, for instance, the Kremlin) may assert based on intercepted phone calls, that the US was behind events in Ukraine, the facts show the opposite to be true: the tail was wagging the dog. Ukraine was a homegrown grassroots movement that the US and Europe sought to take advantage of for their own ends: supporting democracy and dismantling and demilitarizing the remnants of the Soviet empire in Europe. 

So, given all that, how do we fix this? How do we step back from the brink and return to a situation in which international borders are accepted, and people are given the right to determine their own futures, where everyone gets enough of what they want so we can all live in peace?

I believe the road lies through Finland.

After a long history of wars and border disputes with Russia, of being used repeatedly as a pawn in larger struggles, Finland realized that it could only survive as a sovereign democracy in the shadow of a superpower through a strategy of rigorous neutrality and non-alignment. It signed an agreement in 1948 with the Soviet Union where it pledged such neutrality and foreswore NATO and the Marshall Plan. In the process it was never impressed into the Warsaw Pact.

Some in the west derided this strategy, and “Finlandization” became a synonym for appeasement in some circles. But the reality is that it worked. Finland skillfully traversed the Cold War via a treacherous tightrope, emerging as a resilient democracy and one of the most prosperous countries in the world, with an enviable education system and a superb track record in human rights. In 2010, Newsweek magazine, using a variety of matrixes, called Finland “the best country in the world.”

Who would not wish for the same for Ukraine?

So here’s the proposal:

  1. The West accepts Russia’s annexation of Crimea. Yes, Russia’s actions there were wrong according to all international norms. But the fact is that, if Ukrainian constitutional processes for secession had been followed, Crimea would probably have gotten to the same place, just more slowly and peacefully.
  2. Russia removes all troops massing along Ukraine’s borders and pledges to respect, in perpetuity, Ukraine’s sovereignty (renouncing further annexations), signing a bilateral treaty with Ukraine that is a modern equivalent to the Soviet-Finnish treaty of 1948. For its part, Ukraine agrees to explicitly reaffirm its commitment to protecting the rights of all linguistic, ethnic and other minorities.
  3. Ukraine renounces any intention to join NATO and NATO in turn agrees not to make any overtures to Ukraine.
  4. The US, EU and Russia establish a Tripartite Council, to be chaired by the Finnish Foreign Minister, that will be tasked with helping Ukraine out of its current economic morass, overseeing free and fair elections, and ensuring a fully demilitarized, independent, democratic and non-aligned Ukraine in perpetuity. Through this Council, Ukraine will be given unique economic status, eventually granted membership to both the EU and Putin’s Eurasian Union.

As any solution, it requires concessions from all sides, but it accepts the things we cannot change, gets all involved most of what they want, and gets us to the place we all know this has to go: to a free, non-aligned Ukraine.

And there is no reason a similar plan could not be implemented for Georgia and Moldova.


* Why is History feminine? Simple. Because, like a majestic sailing ship, she is far more attractive and intelligent than all the men who think that they have her figured out, that they can manipulate her for their own ends.

Oh, and to pile on yet another irony, it was almost exactly 231 years ago today, on April 8, 1783, that Catherine II ("the Great") issued a decree annexing Crimea to the Russian empire.

Like this post? Get a weekly email digest + member-only deals

Some of Our Books

A Taste of Russia

A Taste of Russia

The definitive modern cookbook on Russian cuisine has been totally updated and redesigned in a 30th Anniversary Edition. Layering superbly researched recipes with informative essays on the dishes' rich historical and cultural context, A Taste of Russia includes over 200 recipes on everything from borshch to blini, from Salmon Coulibiac to Beef Stew with Rum, from Marinated Mushrooms to Walnut-honey Filled Pies. A Taste of Russia shows off the best that Russian cooking has to offer. Full of great quotes from Russian literature about Russian food and designed in a convenient wide format that stays open during use.
The Frogs Who Begged for a Tsar (bilingual)

The Frogs Who Begged for a Tsar (bilingual)

The fables of Ivan Krylov are rich fonts of Russian cultural wisdom and experience – reading and understanding them is vital to grasping the Russian worldview. This new edition of 62 of Krylov’s tales presents them side-by-side in English and Russian. The wonderfully lyrical translations by Lydia Razran Stone are accompanied by original, whimsical color illustrations by Katya Korobkina.
The Samovar Murders

The Samovar Murders

The murder of a poet is always more than a murder. When a famous writer is brutally stabbed on the campus of Moscow’s Lumumba University, the son of a recently deposed African president confesses, and the case assumes political implications that no one wants any part of.
Russian Rules

Russian Rules

From the shores of the White Sea to Moscow and the Northern Caucasus, Russian Rules is a high-speed thriller based on actual events, terrifying possibilities, and some really stupid decisions.
Fish: A History of One Migration

Fish: A History of One Migration

This mesmerizing novel from one of Russia’s most important modern authors traces the life journey of a selfless Russian everywoman. In the wake of the Soviet breakup, inexorable forces drag Vera across the breadth of the Russian empire. Facing a relentless onslaught of human and social trials, she swims against the current of life, countering adversity and pain with compassion and hope, in many ways personifying Mother Russia’s torment and resilience amid the Soviet disintegration.
Moscow and Muscovites

Moscow and Muscovites

Vladimir Gilyarovsky's classic portrait of the Russian capital is one of Russians’ most beloved books. Yet it has never before been translated into English. Until now! It is a spectactular verbal pastiche: conversation, from gutter gibberish to the drawing room; oratory, from illiterates to aristocrats; prose, from boilerplate to Tolstoy; poetry, from earthy humor to Pushkin. 
Turgenev Bilingual

Turgenev Bilingual

A sampling of Ivan Turgenev's masterful short stories, plays, novellas and novels. Bilingual, with English and accented Russian texts running side by side on adjoining pages.
The Latchkey Murders

The Latchkey Murders

Senior Lieutenant Pavel Matyushkin is back on the case in this prequel to the popular mystery Murder at the Dacha, in which a serial killer is on the loose in Khrushchev’s Moscow...

About Us

Russian Life is a publication of a 30-year-young, award-winning publishing house that creates a bimonthly magazine, books, maps, and other products for Russophiles the world over.

Latest Posts

Our Contacts

Russian Life
73 Main Street, Suite 402
Montpelier VT 05602

802-223-4955