December 30, 2024

Trauma or Personal Growth?


Trauma or Personal Growth?
104th Guards Air Assault Regiment.  Ministry of Defence of the Russian Federation, Wikimedia Commons.

Since the start of the full-scale Russian invasion of Ukraine, Russian media have reported not only on crimes committed by former servicemen but also on their good deeds, reports Lyudi Baikala (People of Baikal).

In news reports, former “special operation” participants have been credited with pulling neighbors from fires, finding a missing pensioner in a forest, providing first aid to an airplane passenger, saving a governor during an assassination attempt, and paying off overdue alimony debts. Some former soldiers enter universities, become farmers or teachers, take up professional sports or charity work, and even run for mayor. None of these individuals report psychological problems upon returning, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is rarely mentioned.

In interviews, many military personnel describe how the war helped them rethink their lives. For instance, volunteer fighter Mikhail Lubkov, from Voronezh, called his participation in the war “a positive experience in every sense.” Lyudi Baikala journalists also found soldiers who said they experienced positive changes after fighting in Ukraine. One is 31-year-old Wagner PMC volunteer Artem Dilmuradov, previously convicted of murdering a family of three. Now he is working as a social coordinator for the regional branch of the Fatherland Defenders Foundation. He helps fellow soldiers secure payments and file paperwork. Dilmuradov also visits schools, telling students about what he calls the “cleansing of Bakhmut.”

Another soldier, 39-year-old Viktor Birtolan, returned from the front and started teaching the Law of God at the Gorlitsa Sunday School in a church in Yekaterinburg. He says his time in the war “cleared my brains,” that he “became more responsible,” and that his “sense of justice has become stronger.” Birtolan joined the school in September 2023, six months after leaving the front, where he spent about eight months and sustained multiple concussions.

The notion of positive experiences from war is discussed not only by the media and military personnel but also by Russian psychologists. Professor Mikhail Reshetnikov, rector of the East European Institute of Psychoanalysis and a doctor of psychology, called Russian combatants “the gold fund not only of the army but of the whole society.” He  argued that the danger of developing PTSD is exaggerated, saying, “Everything that does not kill us makes us stronger.”  Moscow-based clinical psychologist Tatyana Uryvchikova compared combat operations to tempering steel. Another psychologist, Langovoy, who fought as a volunteer, said he believes some soldiers experience post-traumatic growth, or positive changes after severe psychological trauma.

Some psychologists say as many as 20 percent of combatants may experience “growth,” a number that could outpace those at risk for developing PTSD. However, many researchers dispute the concept of post-traumatic growth. Anthony Mancini, an American psychologist, called the idea “very attractive” but said there is little concrete evidence, since the theory is mostly based on surveys of people who have experienced trauma. He notes that more in-depth research is needed.

Others caution against understating the danger of psychological trauma. “PTSD won’t develop in everyone, but almost all will have disorders that could emerge years later,” a clinical psychologist from Novosibirsk said on condition of anonymity. “Talking about this in Russia is falling out of favor, and that’s a perilous trend.” Clinical psychologist Fyodor Konkov, who has lived in the United States for many years, said he believes some Russian researchers are confusing “trauma” with “stress.” He said moderate stress can be beneficial but that “excessive stress is harmful to both physical and mental health.” Said Konkov, “If it’s trauma, it’s not beneficial in any dose or form.”

Konkov also suggested that Reshetnikov and other researchers in Russia must “survive under current conditions,” meaning they are pressured to claim there will not be a large number of soldiers with PTSD. Even so, some Russian officials acknowledge the problem. In mid-June 2024, Deputy Defense Minister Anna Tsivileva said every fifth Russian soldier returning from the front has been diagnosed with PTSD, and there are not enough psychologists to meet their needs.

Some soldiers who initially spoke only of the war’s positive impact eventually conceded that combat experience can be problematic. Birtolan, the Sunday school teacher, carries a folding knife with him to his classes because he no longer can imagine going anywhere “without a weapon.” He also recalled an incident when his nine-year-old son put a toy gun to his head; his first reaction, he said, was to kill him.

Speaking of which, no scientific study or psychological analysis could find any positive result out of war for those who never return. As the old saying goes, "war doesn't decide who is right, but who is left."

You Might Also Like

A Memory Battle, Won
  • December 22, 2024

A Memory Battle, Won

A statue to the founder of the Soviet secret police has been erected in Khabarovsk.
Ghost of Economy Future
  • December 15, 2024

Ghost of Economy Future

Russian analysts give their forecasts for what the economy might look like in early 2025.
Like this post? Get a weekly email digest + member-only deals

Some of Our Books

The Samovar Murders

The Samovar Murders

The murder of a poet is always more than a murder. When a famous writer is brutally stabbed on the campus of Moscow’s Lumumba University, the son of a recently deposed African president confesses, and the case assumes political implications that no one wants any part of.
Woe From Wit (bilingual)

Woe From Wit (bilingual)

One of the most famous works of Russian literature, the four-act comedy in verse Woe from Wit skewers staid, nineteenth century Russian society, and it positively teems with “winged phrases” that are essential colloquialisms for students of Russian and Russian culture.
Bears in the Caviar

Bears in the Caviar

Bears in the Caviar is a hilarious and insightful memoir by a diplomat who was “present at the creation” of US-Soviet relations. Charles Thayer headed off to Russia in 1933, calculating that if he could just learn Russian and be on the spot when the US and USSR established relations, he could make himself indispensable and start a career in the foreign service. Remarkably, he pulled it of.
Faith & Humor: Notes from Muscovy

Faith & Humor: Notes from Muscovy

A book that dares to explore the humanity of priests and pilgrims, saints and sinners, Faith & Humor has been both a runaway bestseller in Russia and the focus of heated controversy – as often happens when a thoughtful writer takes on sacred cows. The stories, aphorisms, anecdotes, dialogues and adventures in this volume comprise an encyclopedia of modern Russian Orthodoxy, and thereby of Russian life.
Marooned in Moscow

Marooned in Moscow

This gripping autobiography plays out against the backdrop of Russia's bloody Civil War, and was one of the first Western eyewitness accounts of life in post-revolutionary Russia. Marooned in Moscow provides a fascinating account of one woman's entry into war-torn Russia in early 1920, first-person impressions of many in the top Soviet leadership, and accounts of the author's increasingly dangerous work as a journalist and spy, to say nothing of her work on behalf of prisoners, her two arrests, and her eventual ten-month-long imprisonment, including in the infamous Lubyanka prison. It is a veritable encyclopedia of life in Russia in the early 1920s.
Stargorod: A Novel in Many Voices

Stargorod: A Novel in Many Voices

Stargorod is a mid-sized provincial city that exists only in Russian metaphorical space. It has its roots in Gogol, and Ilf and Petrov, and is a place far from Moscow, but close to Russian hearts. It is a place of mystery and normality, of provincial innocence and Black Earth wisdom. Strange, inexplicable things happen in Stargorod. So do good things. And bad things. A lot like life everywhere, one might say. Only with a heavy dose of vodka, longing and mystery.
The Moscow Eccentric

The Moscow Eccentric

Advance reviewers are calling this new translation "a coup" and "a remarkable achievement." This rediscovered gem of a novel by one of Russia's finest writers explores some of the thorniest issues of the early twentieth century.
At the Circus (bilingual)

At the Circus (bilingual)

This wonderful novella by Alexander Kuprin tells the story of the wrestler Arbuzov and his battle against a renowned American wrestler. Rich in detail and characterization, At the Circus brims with excitement and life. You can smell the sawdust in the big top, see the vivid and colorful characters, sense the tension build as Arbuzov readies to face off against the American.
Steppe / Степь (bilingual)

Steppe / Степь (bilingual)

This is the work that made Chekhov, launching his career as a writer and playwright of national and international renown. Retranslated and updated, this new bilingual edition is a super way to improve your Russian.

About Us

Russian Life is a publication of a 30-year-young, award-winning publishing house that creates a bimonthly magazine, books, maps, and other products for Russophiles the world over.

Latest Posts

Our Contacts

Russian Life
73 Main Street, Suite 402
Montpelier VT 05602

802-223-4955