March 14, 2021

A Memory Battle for Lubyanka Square


A Memory Battle for Lubyanka Square
The former KGB building, Lubyanka Square. Griffin Edwards

Lubyanka Square in Central Moscow is a place brimming with history. It's also the location of one of Moscow's latest controversies.

While it may seem like a fairly ordinary, urban, metro-serviced plaza, it's been a feature of Russia's capital for centuries. It's the intersection of numerous large streets, and is mere steps away from the Kremlin, Red Square, and the Bolshoi Theater. Lubyanka is right at the center of Moscow's beating heart.

Lubyanka Square is most infamous for housing the Lubyanka Building, a massive, orangish, Stalinist-neoclassical pastiche that was once the headquarters of the KGB (and, pre-revolutionarily, an insurance company building): thousands of Russians passed through its side gate, never to return. Today, it houses the FSB, successor to the KGB and essentially Russia's counterpart to the FBI and CIA rolled into one. A memorial stone stands across the street to pay homage to the victims of political oppression.

The center of Lubyanka Square is surprisingly unadorned. Originally, there was a fountain in front of the building. However, in 1958, the fountain was replaced with a statue of Felix Dzerzhinsky, founder of the Cheka, the KGB's no more humanitarian predecessor.

Lubyanka Square with the old statue of Dzerzhinsky.
Lubyanka Square, pre-1991. | RIA Novosti archive / Wikicommons.

This monument was torn down by citizens in 1991, in the chaos that came with the fall of the Soviet Union. It was moved into storage, and ever since an awkward green patch has sat before one of the most imposing buildings in Russia.

This February, however, Moscow city authorities put a vote before the people: would citizens prefer Dzerzhinsky refurbished and re-plinthed, or would they prefer a new statue of Alexander Nevsky? Other options, such creating as a new fountain or simply leaving the space empty, were rejected by city authorities.

Alexander Nevsky is a bit of a random choice. The thirteenth-century Novgorodian prince is best known for his canny diplomacy during the period of Mongol invasions, defending Russia's sovereignty when beset by Teutonic crusaders, Swedish raiders, and Asiatic hordes. Today, he's an Orthodox saint.

Nevsky and Dzerzhinsky represent vastly different things. Dzerzhinsky helped engineer one of the most repressive systems in history, while Nevsky defended Russia in a difficult time of its history. Placing a symbol of either in the center of Moscow would send a message. Which one to send, however, was in the hands of Muscovites.

There's a whole scholarly ecosystem in the field of "collective memory," which explores issues like those raised here. A hybrid of anthropology and history, researchers look to the phenomenons of commemorations, education, museums, and pop history to see how and why different historical events are remembered. It's a fascinating field, and one with continuing relevance.

Alexander Nevsky Square, Petersburg
Alexander Nevsky Square, St. Petersburg. No, the trolleybus lines above the streets are not part of the original monument. | Kuds, Wikimedia Commons

One of collective memory's main lessons is that historical retellings are normative: that is, they tell people who they ought to be, what they ought to do, and how they ought to act in a society. Widespread Russian commemoration of the Second World War, for example, is thought to be President Vladimir Putin's way of instilling Russian patriotism and nationalism into new generations, reminding them that defense of one's homeland is an important part of being Russian. In short, current political concerns are strategically reinforced and legitimized through the past. Therefore, what societies choose to remember (and forget!) is extremely revealing. Statues and other commemorations promote certain values, advertising them as something desirable.

Unfortunately, before we could see whether Russians would support the repressive legacy of Dzerzhinsky or the faithful piety of Nevsky, the voting was stopped. Nevsky had garnered 55% of 320,000 votes cast; the Cheka founder, 45%. The city cited vitriol in calling off the poll, and has chosen instead to keep the center of the square un-monumented.

Crisis averted? Maybe. But in a country with a history as tumultuous as Russia's, another crisis is probably right around the corner.

But Russia isn't the only country to do this (and we here at RL love to revel in the likes of train-borne World War II museums, collective memory is a global phenomenon). While the field doesn't provide a clear answer to the question of what to do with those pesky Confederate monuments, it does provide us with a bit of a theoretical framework.

In short, we here in the States aren't the only ones trying to deal with a complex history.

 

You Might Also Like

Idols and Anniversaries
  • November 01, 2014

Idols and Anniversaries

The Wall and Iron Felix may be gone, but one important thing never happened, which explains plenty about modern Russian politics.
The Wallenberg Secret
  • November 01, 2017

The Wallenberg Secret

The disappearance of Raoul Wallenberg remains just that. But need it be?
Russia's Political Tool
  • January 01, 1998

Russia's Political Tool

December 20, 1997 is the 80th anniversary of the KGB. We look back at the sordid history of this nefarious institution.
Confessions of an Illegal
  • January 01, 2008

Confessions of an Illegal

He lived secretly in the West under deep cover, working in offices, at dry cleaners, as a trade representative. He gathered intelligence deemed critical to the Soviet state. Now, he's talking to us.
Spetsluzhb Goes to the Movies
  • November 01, 2006

Spetsluzhb Goes to the Movies

The FSB (heir to the KGB) has been influencing Russia’s recent film releases. Propaganda is new again.
Memories of Perestroika
  • March 01, 2010

Memories of Perestroika

Malcolm Gilbert, a longtime observer of things Russian and Soviet who has been leading academic trips to Russia for over three decades, casts his gaze back to consider the changes perestroika wrought...
Like this post? Get a weekly email digest + member-only deals

Some of Our Books

Davai! The Russians and Their Vodka

Davai! The Russians and Their Vodka

In this comprehensive, quixotic and addictive book, Edwin Trommelen explores all facets of the Russian obsession with vodka. Peering chiefly through the lenses of history and literature, Trommelen offers up an appropriately complex, rich and bittersweet portrait, based on great respect for Russian culture.
Marooned in Moscow

Marooned in Moscow

This gripping autobiography plays out against the backdrop of Russia's bloody Civil War, and was one of the first Western eyewitness accounts of life in post-revolutionary Russia. Marooned in Moscow provides a fascinating account of one woman's entry into war-torn Russia in early 1920, first-person impressions of many in the top Soviet leadership, and accounts of the author's increasingly dangerous work as a journalist and spy, to say nothing of her work on behalf of prisoners, her two arrests, and her eventual ten-month-long imprisonment, including in the infamous Lubyanka prison. It is a veritable encyclopedia of life in Russia in the early 1920s.
Dostoyevsky Bilingual

Dostoyevsky Bilingual

Bilingual series of short, lesser known, but highly significant works that show the traditional view of Dostoyevsky as a dour, intense, philosophical writer to be unnecessarily one-sided. 
Fish: A History of One Migration

Fish: A History of One Migration

This mesmerizing novel from one of Russia’s most important modern authors traces the life journey of a selfless Russian everywoman. In the wake of the Soviet breakup, inexorable forces drag Vera across the breadth of the Russian empire. Facing a relentless onslaught of human and social trials, she swims against the current of life, countering adversity and pain with compassion and hope, in many ways personifying Mother Russia’s torment and resilience amid the Soviet disintegration.
The Frogs Who Begged for a Tsar (bilingual)

The Frogs Who Begged for a Tsar (bilingual)

The fables of Ivan Krylov are rich fonts of Russian cultural wisdom and experience – reading and understanding them is vital to grasping the Russian worldview. This new edition of 62 of Krylov’s tales presents them side-by-side in English and Russian. The wonderfully lyrical translations by Lydia Razran Stone are accompanied by original, whimsical color illustrations by Katya Korobkina.
Murder at the Dacha

Murder at the Dacha

Senior Lieutenant Pavel Matyushkin has a problem. Several, actually. Not the least of them is the fact that a powerful Soviet boss has been murdered, and Matyushkin's surly commander has given him an unreasonably short time frame to close the case.
Moscow and Muscovites

Moscow and Muscovites

Vladimir Gilyarovsky's classic portrait of the Russian capital is one of Russians’ most beloved books. Yet it has never before been translated into English. Until now! It is a spectactular verbal pastiche: conversation, from gutter gibberish to the drawing room; oratory, from illiterates to aristocrats; prose, from boilerplate to Tolstoy; poetry, from earthy humor to Pushkin. 
The Little Humpbacked Horse (bilingual)

The Little Humpbacked Horse (bilingual)

A beloved Russian classic about a resourceful Russian peasant, Vanya, and his miracle-working horse, who together undergo various trials, exploits and adventures at the whim of a laughable tsar, told in rich, narrative poetry.
Life Stories: Original Fiction By Russian Authors

Life Stories: Original Fiction By Russian Authors

The Life Stories collection is a nice introduction to contemporary Russian fiction: many of the 19 authors featured here have won major Russian literary prizes and/or become bestsellers. These are life-affirming stories of love, family, hope, rebirth, mystery and imagination, masterfully translated by some of the best Russian-English translators working today. The selections reassert the power of Russian literature to affect readers of all cultures in profound and lasting ways. Best of all, 100% of the profits from the sale of this book are going to benefit Russian hospice—not-for-profit care for fellow human beings who are nearing the end of their own life stories.

About Us

Russian Life is a publication of a 30-year-young, award-winning publishing house that creates a bimonthly magazine, books, maps, and other products for Russophiles the world over.

Latest Posts

Our Contacts

Russian Life
73 Main Street, Suite 402
Montpelier VT 05602

802-223-4955